| Year | Title | Trophy |
| 1920 | MDCA Premier League Champions | Stockton Trophy (first year awarded) |
| 1927 | MDCA 2nd XI Champions | Burrows Trophy |
| 1938 | MDCA Premier League Champions | Stockton Trophy |
| 1947 | MDCA Premier League Champions | Stockton Trophy |
| 1974 | MDCA 1st XI Knock-Out Cup | H C Smith Trophy |
| 1980 | MDCA 1st XI Division One Champions | Arthur Bewick Trophy |
| 1980 | SMJL Under 15 Champions | |
| 1981 | SMJL Under 15 Champions | |
| 1984 | SMJL Under 18 Champions | Jerry Blight Trophy |
| 1986 | SMJL Under 18 Champions | Jerry Blight Trophy |
| 1989 | SMJL Under 15 Champions | |
| 1990 | MDCA 1st XI Division One Champions | Arthur Bewick Trophy |
| 1998 | SMJL Under 18 League | Top Four Trophy |
| 1999 | SMJL Under 18 League | Top Four Trophy |
| 2000 | CCCL 2nd XI Division Two Champions | Newton Trophy |
| 2004 | CCL 2nd XI Division A Champions | |
| 2004 | CCL 2nd XI Knock-Out Cup | |
| 2004 | CCCL Sunday 3rd XI Division 4 Champions | Bloor Trophy |
